Best of Mystic compass logo
Best of Mystic
Best Pizza

Best Pizza

From the legendary 'slice of heaven' to wood-fired Neapolitan — ranked

Filter
3 of 3
#1
Top Pick
#1 · Best of Mystic

Mystic Pizza

4.5
Local Guide Verdict

The iconic spot from the Julia Roberts film — still slinging the 'slice of heaven' decades later.

56 W Main St, Mystic
Walk-in only · No reservations
#2
#2 · Best of Mystic

Angie's Pizza

4.4
Local Guide Verdict

Old-school Connecticut-style pizza that locals have loved for generations.

10 Clift St, Mystic
Walk-in only · No reservations
#3
#3 · Best of Mystic

Nana's Mystic

4.7
Local Guide Verdict

Wood-fired Neapolitan pies with farm-fresh toppings and a serious crust game.

7 Water St, Mystic
Walk-in only · No reservations
Explore Mystic

The Local's Map

Filter by what you're after — every pin is a hand-picked local favorite.

Loading map…
#MysticCT

Best Pizza — From #MysticCT

Curated picks for Best Pizza

Sunset over Mystic harbor
@mysticct.local
412 18
Mystic harbor at night
@coastal.ct
287 22
Bascule bridge from the lawn
@seaport.life
356 11
Mystic sunset over the village
@mysticgram
521 34
Bridge-up crowd
@bridge.watch
198 9
Quiet harbor dock
@hidden.mystic
145 6
Boardwalk lights
@mysticct.local
310 14
4th of July over the river
@mysticgram
824 47
Insider Access

The Mystic Insider List

Curated local picks, seasonal events, and quiet-season perks — sent only when something truly worth knowing comes ashore.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your info.

Local Spotlight
Promote your Mystic business here
Advertise →
Local Spotlight
Promote your Mystic business here
Advertise →