#1
Top Pick
#1 · Best of Mystic
Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream
4.9
Local Guide VerdictLegendary homemade ice cream right by the drawbridge. Lines around the block in summer.
2 W Main StIce CreamIconic
Walk-in only · No reservations
Best Foodie Picks
Ice cream, fries, desserts, and the most unique dishes in Mystic
Mystic Foodie Scenes
Downtown — where Mystic's best foodie spots line the streets
Filter
5 of 5
#2
#2 · Best of Mystic
Friar Tuck's
4.7
Local Guide VerdictCrispy, perfectly seasoned fries that are a Mystic institution.
20 W Main StFriesCasual
Walk-in only · No reservations
#3
#3 · Best of Mystic
Sift Bake Shop
4.8
Local Guide VerdictArtisan pastries and desserts. The croissants are next-level.
5 Water StDessertsBakery
Walk-in only · No reservations
#4
#4 · Best of Mystic
Mystic Pizza
4.5
Local Guide VerdictThe OG — a novelty dish you have to try at least once.
56 W Main StNoveltyPizza
Walk-in only · No reservations
#5
#5 · Best of Mystic
Harp & Hound
4.8
Local Guide VerdictLocals call it 'Wicked Awesome Sauce with Fries' — ask for Mia, she knows the real Irish name. Cozy Irish pub vibes downtown.
4 Pearl St, MysticIrish PubLocal Secret
Walk-in only · No reservations
Explore Mystic
The Local's Map
Filter by what you're after — every pin is a hand-picked local favorite.
Loading map…
#MysticCT
Best Foodie Picks — From #MysticCT
Curated picks for Best Foodie Picks
Insider Access
The Mystic Insider List
Curated local picks, seasonal events, and quiet-season perks — sent only when something truly worth knowing comes ashore.