Best of MysticCreated by Locals…Who Live and Love the Mystic “Locale”

Best Bloody Mary

Best Bloody Mary

Spicy, briny, garnished within an inch of its life — the Mystic Bloody Mary list

Filter

5 of 5

#1

Top Pick

#1 · Best of Mystic

Captain Daniel Packer Inne

4.9

Local Guide Verdict
House mix with horseradish kick, served in a pint glass with a pickled spear and shrimp.

32 Water St, MysticBrunchSpicy

#2

#2 · Best of Mystic

Red 36

4.7

Local Guide Verdict
Waterfront brunch favorite — Bloody Mary bar with celery, bacon, blue cheese olives.

2 Washington St, MysticBrunch BarWaterfront

#3

#3 · Best of Mystic

Engine Room

4.7

Local Guide Verdict
Smoked salt rim, fresh tomato base — the most chef-driven Bloody in town.

14 Holmes St, MysticCraftSmoky

#4

#4 · Best of Mystic

Harbour House Restaurant

4.6

Local Guide Verdict
Classic build with a cold beer back — the Sunday morning order.

15 Water St, MysticClassicBeer Back

Walk-in only · No reservations

#5

#5 · Best of Mystic

S&P Oyster Bar

4.6

Local Guide Verdict
Add a raw oyster shooter — locals' favorite Bloody upgrade.

1 Holmes St, MysticOyster Shooter

Explore Mystic

The Local's Map

Filter by what you're after — every pin is a hand-picked local favorite.

Loading map…

#MysticCT

Best Bloody Mary — From #MysticCT

Curated picks for Best Bloody Mary

@mysticct.local

@mysticct.local

Insider Access

The Mystic Insider List

Curated local picks, seasonal events, and quiet-season perks — sent only when something truly worth knowing comes ashore.

Local Spotlight

Promote your Mystic business here

Editor's Picks

Best Bloody Mary Bars — Flip For Build Notes

Each card flips to reveal the house build — heat, garnish stack, and whether to add the oyster shooter.

Local FAQ

Mystic Bloody Mary FAQ

Local Spotlight

Promote your Mystic business here